Skip to content
We Are Motor
Blog September 13, 2026 6 min read

“Extremely treacherous”: what was said about Monaco in 1929 and about every new circuit since

Dangerous, artificial, badly finished, impossible to overtake on. It is what was said about the Madring this week and what has been said about every new circuit since 1929. We went back to the debuts of six historic layouts, and the pattern that emerges explains a good deal more than this weekend's noise.

Written by Andrés Rendón

Founder and host of Somos Motor, September 13, 2026

In 1929, Motor Sport magazine described a new circuit as “extremely treacherous”, with innumerable corners and two hairpins, and recorded the doubts of many people about whether it could be raced safely among buildings, kerbs and the wall of a harbour.

It was talking about Monaco. Ninety-seven years later, that circuit is the most prestigious Grand Prix on the calendar.

This week in Madrid, drivers have said of the Madring that it is possibly the riskiest of the year, a car killer and a place where you cannot overtake. Before deciding what that means, it is worth looking at what was said about the others when they debuted.

01Monaco, 1929: the street circuit nobody thought viable

It was organised by Antony Noghès with sixteen invited entrants and 100,000 francs in prize money. William Grover-Williams won in a Bugatti T35B.

The criticisms of the time are, word for word, those of any street circuit today: narrow streets, walls close by, impossible to race safely. When Monaco joined the world championship in 1950, Fangio won it from start to finish, taking the first grand slam in history, in a race in which Farina caused a nine-car accident.

The start/finish straight and control tower of the Jarama circuit, in San Sebastián de los Reyes
Foto: Agence Rol / Biblioteca Nacional de Francia (dominio público).

02Spa, 1950: when dangerous meant dangerous

Here the adjective was not rhetorical.

The first Belgian Grand Prix to count for the championship was won by Fangio on 18 June 1950, on a 14.12-kilometre layout of forest roads. In the 1960s, ten people died at that circuit. In 1960 alone, Chris Bristow and Alan Stacey were killed, and Stirling Moss and Mike Taylor were seriously injured in practice that same week.

In 1969, the drivers outright boycotted the Grand Prix. The layout ended up shortened and transformed, and today Spa is one of the temples of motorsport.

03Jarama, 1968: the direct precedent for Madrid

This is the one that really matters for understanding this week, because it is the last time Madrid had Formula 1.

The first championship Grand Prix at Jarama was run on 12 May 1968 and won by Graham Hill in a Lotus 49, climbing from seventh place. Chris Amon took his first pole with Ferrari.

It was run at a brutal moment: it was the first race since the death of Jim Clark, six weeks earlier.

And Jarama's ending is the part worth keeping in mind. The last Grand Prix there was on 21 June 1981, and it was an extraordinary race: Gilles Villeneuve won it, his last Formula 1 victory, with five cars separated by 1.24 seconds at the finish line. One of the tightest finishes in history.

The circuit did not disappear because of a tragedy. It disappeared through wear: a narrow track, facilities that had become outdated, unpopularity among the drivers and fees left unpaid in 1981. It went gradually.

That was exactly 45 years ago, and it is the figure that explains why Madrid was news even before a car had turned a wheel.

04Montjuïc, 1975: the counterpoint that has to be told in full

Barcelona had its own street circuit, and its history is what stops us treating this conversation as a fans' debate.

At its first championship event in 1969, Jackie Stewart won, and the race went down in history for the wing crisis: the Lotuses of Graham Hill and Jochen Rindt crashed when the rear wing mounts broke. The FIA ended up banning those tall wings.

On 27 April 1975, on lap 26, the rear wing came off Rolf Stommelen's car. The car was flung over the spectators. Four people died: the fireman Joaquín Benaches Morera, the spectator Andrés Ruiz Villanova and the photojournalists Mario de Roia and Antonio Font Bayarri.

And what makes this case especially hard is that there had been a warning. The drivers' association went on strike on arriving at the circuit over the state of the guardrail: loose or missing bolts, gaps between sections, stretches that threatened to open up. The organisers responded with legal threats. Emerson Fittipaldi announced on the morning of the race that he did not intend to race and left: he is listed as a non-starter. His brother Wilson and Arturo Merzario did take the start, and retired in protest as soon as they got going.

Montjuïc never hosted a Grand Prix again.

The start/finish straight and control tower of the Jarama circuit, in San Sebastián de los Reyes
Foto: TintaBCN (CC BY-SA 4.0).

05Barcelona-Catalunya, 1991: the debut that went well

Not everything is controversy. The Catalan circuit opened in 1991 and immediately produced one of the most replayed images in the history of the sport: Mansell and Senna arriving at the first corner wheel to wheel, with sparks flying from their floors and looking each other in the eye at more than 300 kilometres per hour.

Mansell won. Nobody remembers a complaint from that weekend.

06The modern ones: Jeddah, Miami, Las Vegas

And the last three street circuits on the calendar repeat the script with an almost identical vocabulary:

  • Jeddah (2021): absolute chaos at its debut. Sergio Pérez called it “pointlessly dangerous”. George Russell said motorsport had a lot to learn from that day.
  • Miami (2022): the drivers complained about the uneven asphalt from the first lap, to the point that it had to be patched during the weekend. The layout's own designer admitted to feeling embarrassed. Even so, the race produced 45 overtakes and tickets had sold out in forty minutes.
  • Las Vegas (2023): the problem was not the driving. A loose drain cover wrecked Sainz's Ferrari in the first practice session, the session was cancelled, the next one was delayed to half past two in the morning and the crowd was cleared. It ended in a class action against the organisers.

07The pattern, and what separates one case from another

Seen in a row, these eight debuts tell us three things:

One: the complaint is always the same. Dangerous, artificial, narrow, badly finished, impossible to overtake on. It is the same text in 1929 and in 2026, and on its own it does not tell a bad circuit from one that will become legendary.

Two: what matters is not the complaint, it is the consequence. When the criticism stays at discomfort, as at Monaco, Miami or Jeddah, the circuit survives and sometimes becomes a legend. When the criticism points to real negligence, as at Montjuïc or the Spa of the sixties, the track disappears or is redesigned entirely. The difference between one case and the other is not set by the tone of the statements: it is set by whether anyone heeded the warning.

Three: Jarama shows the third way to die, which is neither tragedy nor glory. It is wear. A circuit that becomes outdated, that bothers the drivers, that piles up management problems, and that one day is no longer on the calendar without anyone remembering a specific date.

Madrid has a contract until 2035. Which of the three paths it takes is not decided this Sunday.

The count of what has happened this weekend, with the comparison of crashes against other recent street-circuit debuts, is in Is the Madring dangerous?. And the context of the circuit and its contract is in what the Madring is.

Email alerts

We will alert you about this section

We will alert you about all sections Change

Sections

Turn on notifications

The day before, the time of every session and where to watch it.